Nov 17, 2019
Sam and Dean each try to tell their side of a story to Bobby as the two are mad at one another. But is someone just playing a trick on them?
We're joined by Jess' friend (and our Fandom Trumps Hate auction winner) Martha! We learn what children name their toys and books to read (for a while), discover that Sam has...
Nov 10, 2019
Sam goes missing and when Dean catches up, something bad has definitely happened. Is Sam turning into the monster he feared he would become?
We debate about Bon Jovi, wonder if Jess' husband Matt should be a surrogate for our Matt, and Jess' dog Luna makes her first appearance.
Nov 3, 2019
Is it a vengeful spirit or an avenging angel? Will Sam kill an innocent person? Will Dean fess up to his actual emotional issues?
Look none of that matters. What matters is when you feel spiritual ecstasy, your perm goes away. We also may trail off into some more serious conversation for once. Just a bit. A...
Oct 27, 2019
Sam and Dean have to track down a Man-Droid! Well...if you believe the very unstable night guardsman at the bank where they accidentally take a bunch of people hostage leading the FBI to try and stop them. Look, it’s really complicated!
We are joined by Alisha Grauso, film critic, editorial lead of Atom Tickets, and...
Oct 20, 2019
There's creepy children so you know it's going to be a good one! We also see the ground work laid for Dean's crush on Daphne. Don't worry. Just another 11 seasons for it to payoff!
We then get into a discussion about Dean overcompensating. Is it part of the character? It is the writers baiting fans? Is it just done for...